RSS

Aging Aircraft of US Airlines: Safety Issue or Just a Service Issue?

This entry was posted on Feb 04 2010 by Allen Howell

A  February 1 article by A. Pawlowski of CNN titled “How old is the plane you’re flying on?” says the following: “Few people expect luxury while flying, but these days, even the basics seem to be in bad shape. It’s not uncommon to find your tray table broken, the in-flight entertainment system not working and your seat cushion worn — all of which can make you think, how old is this plane anyway?”

“But for now, the reality for many U.S. air travelers is that most of their journeys take place on planes that have been in service for a decade or more and show it, though in ways that have no impact on their safety – like worn interiors, broken creature comforts and less than spotless conditions.”

Sounds more like riding on the metro rail than flying on an aircraft. Maybe that is what the experience ends up being in the future? Mass transit by Air! 

 The article goes on to discuss the age of the aircraft fleet in the United States and says the following:

The average age of the fleet of the seven large U.S. passenger airlines – including American, Alaska, Continental, the merged Delta and Northwest, Southwest, United and US Airways – is about 14 years old, according to The Airline Monitor. It found American and Delta/Northwest had the oldest fleets, at about 16 years on average. As of the end of 2008, a small percentage of the merged Delta/Northwest’s planes dated back to the late 1960s.

U.S. fleets are among the oldest in the world, said Richard Aboulafia, an aviation analyst at the Teal Group in Fairfax, Virginia.

So all of this begs the question about safety and are these aircraft still safe?

Most everyone will agree, as do the experts quoted in the article, that the fleet of airline aircraft in the United States are maintained to the highest standards in the world and that they are safe. The safety record of US airlines have continued to improve each decade due to good maintenance, technology upgrades in the cockpit and better training of pilots and maintenance personnel.

I have no fear of getting on a 16-year-old aircraft operated by a major air carrier in this country and no worry about arriving safely. The professionals who fly and maintain these aircraft are the best in the world, in spite of the bad press of a very few isolated incidents where the pilots are “working on their laptops” and forget where they are.

The Airline Industry is Safe! But what about the experience?

Is the traveling public going to resign themselves to the idea that all they can expect is to safely arrive? That’s all you expect when you hop on the metro rail in any major city.

There is an alternative for the traveler - it’s called private aviation or business aviation and it’s anything but the same old experience!

Highlight any portion you want: Use a Highlighter on this page
Share and Enjoy:
  • Print
  • Digg
  • Sphinn
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Mixx
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Blogplay
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Yahoo! Buzz


3 Responses to “Aging Aircraft of US Airlines: Safety Issue or Just a Service Issue?”

  1. If you are ever in one of the old DC-9s or MD-80s, you understand just how much better the new airplanes are. Much quieter and more comfortable (if you can call a coach seat comfortable). Theoretically, an airframe should last indefinitely with proper maintenance. However, what concerns me with the airlines these days has been the outsourcing of maintenance to other countries with limited control over quality and especially safety. The recent USAToday article was an eye openers (though I am not a huge fan of that paper after their biased stories about GA). The real problem is the “race to the bottom” for the airlines and that includes maintenance. While I dont believe ANY airline is sacraficing safety over money, there are too many other issues that should give any airline travler pause, especially with international maintenance proceudures with limited TSA oversight. Newer fleets in the airlines will be more the results of the efficencies that the new aircraft can bring over enhancing the passenger experience.

    Business Aviation is a COMPLETELY different experience. While there are older business jets, most are kept impeccibly. After all, the owner or charter customer should expect no less. The ability to board your own airplane with strict controls on maintenance (done DOMESTICALLY) in almost all cases and the comfort and service unmatched by ANY airline clearly gives GA the advantage. Its up to us in the business aviation community to communicate these advantages.


  1. 2 Trackback(s)

  2. Aging Aircraft of US Airlines: Safety Issue or Just a Service … | Tailspin
  3. uberVU - social comments

Post a Comment